Mgt301A Ethics | Ethical Issues Assessment Answers

In Part A, you will address the following questions:

1.What are two ethical economic, commercial, social or environmental issues that must be managed by contemporary organisations?

2.What are two ethical frameworks that can help inform you about how to best manage these issues?

Answer:

Introduction

Dairy farming is an economic activity that involves the use of moral foundation in determining issues concerned with the rightness or wrongness of decisions made in the daily practice of the profession. Morality of actions when dealing with the cows, the production of milk, and the management of the resources generated for profitability and sustainability of assets involved require contemplation of the necessary moral values in the profession (Sandøe & Christiansen, 2013). According to Brown University (2018), the morality of an action depends on the implication it has on the agent of action and the related impacts on the subjects involved.

Summary of Issues and Frameworks Discussed in Part A

The matters articulated in part A of the assignment involves the morality of actions when dealing with dairy cows. Notably, the cows give birth to calves that are separated from their mothers denying them a lactating spell to bolster their growth and development (Villanueva, 2016). Notably, the alienation of the calves with their mothers happens before they have learned the herding behaviors necessary for them to survive on their own. These actions are ethically wrong for the calves and their mothers because they suffer psychological and physiological deprivation (Greek & Menache, 2013). In the words of Alford & Signori (2014), virtue ethics elucidates this moral situation as the farmers focus on the economic benefits they acquire from the dairy farming without focusing on the effects they have on the cows and their offspring. Notwithstanding, cows are slaughtered for meat after a period of milk production when they cease producing milk eliciting fairness or justice application of morality that offers individuals with the opportunity to consider if their actions are fair to others.

Reflection of future workplace behavior

Notably, my passion for animals, their health, and rights make me want to become a veterinary officer in the future. According to Rowlands (2013), animals especially domestic ones are exposed to various dangers by their keepers something that requires critical focus to ensure their safety. Indeed, all animals have rights and denying some of the creation of the right to enjoy life implies that there are ethical gaps that require urgent attention from stakeholders (Greek & Menache, 2013). Mostly, human beings have used some unfounded justification to misuse animals, and dairy farmers are on the onslaught for overemphasizing on making money and neglecting the lives of their dairy animals. As a veterinary officer, I intend sanity among dairy farmers for sustainable and responsible dairy farming. The two moral foundations that are virtue ethics and justice and fairness approach will help me draw lines of interaction and help farmers know how they can rear their animals under a mutual benefit.

Virtue ethical approach is imperative in making dairy farming a success for both farmers and their animals. Virtue ethics emphasize that there are specific ideas through individuals should make decisions (Alford & Signori, 2014). These principles provide for the full realization of humanity and kindness through critical reflection of what we yearn of becoming. Under the ethical approach, human beings ought to act with specific values such as compassion, love, generosity, and integrity among others (Brown University, 2018). Therefore, I intend to help dairy farmers realize that there is a way that they acquire maximum productivity form their animals even without mistreating them and denying their calves an opportunity to spend time with their mothers.    

Everyone requires fairness including animals and plants. The justice approach to ethics highlights whether an action by an agent leads to favoritism or discrimination to the subject (Baumard et al., 2013). According to Brown University (2013), the ethical approach allows agents to treat others otherwise in case they are morally difference between them and their targets. However, there is a need for consistency in fairness something that is absent among dairy farmers. Notably, cows give milk and calves to farmers, and they end up slaughtering them once they can no longer produce milk. Therefore, there lapsing of the principle of fairness in dairy farming as farmers forget the good times they spent with the animals and turn hostile on them (Greek & Menache, 2013). Therefore, as a veterinary officer, I will ensure that farmers act with justice and fairness towards their animals.  Notably, I will help dairy farmers realize that they can take care of their animals whose production has depreciated and supported them until their time to die comes.

However, daily farming is a bug industry and there are senior management officers who may collude with farmers in their practice. Therefore, it may be difficult to implement some of the ethical principles I intend to implement amidst opposition from senior officers in the veterinary service (Klerkx & Nettle, 2013). Notably, dairy farming is an established organization in Australia with most farmers practicing animal rearing as an economic activity. It makes the industry a profit making business and changing the trend may receive significant opposition from stakeholders. Despite the idea of commercialization of daily farming, there is some boost of the ethical standards while dealing with the animals because the veterinary board in Australia supports fair treatment of animals (Barkema et al., 2015). The code of ethics discussed in this report may be used to develop an ethical culture in daily farming. The development of the ethical will involve educating and supporting farmers to realize the need for fair treatment of the dairy animals. Therefore, farmers and the veterinary board will be given the opportunity to practice and understand the different forms of ethical foundations and how they are applicable when dealing with their dairy animals.

Conclusion

All creation deserves equal treatment regardless of their nature. However, human beings have taken advantage and exploited other creatures to create wealth. Dairy farmers have been at the forefront of exploiting their animals through commercializing their products to the extent of neglecting their off springs. As a veterinary officer, I will ensure that I educate dairy farmers on the right treatment of their dairy animals using virtue and justices approaches of morality that emphasizes mutual and equal treatment among interacting agents. Respect for each other ensures that they continue benefiting from one another.

References

Alford, H., & Signori, S. (2014). Brief considerations on the effectiveness of shareholder activism. A virtue ethics approach. Impresa Progetto-Electronic Journal of Management, 3, 1-10.

Barkema, H. W., Von Keyserlingk, M. A. G., Kastelic, J. P., Lam, T. J. G. M., Luby, C., Roy, J. P., ... & Kelton, D. F. (2015). Invited review: Changes in the dairy industry affecting dairy cattle health and welfare. Journal of Dairy Science, 98(11), 7426-7445.

Baumard, N., André, J. B., & Sperber, D. (2013). A mutualistic approach to morality: The evolution of fairness by partner choice. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 36(1), 59-78.

Brown University, B.W. (2018). A Framework for Making Ethical Decisions. Retrieved 5 July, 2018, from https://www.brown.edu/academics/science-and-technology-studies/framework-making-ethical-decisions

Greek, R., & Menache, A. (2013). Systematic reviews of animal models: methodology versus epistemology. International journal of medical sciences, 10(3), 206.

Klerkx, L., & Nettle, R. (2013). Achievements and challenges of innovation co-production support initiatives in the Australian and Dutch dairy sectors: a comparative study. Food Policy, 40, 74-89. 

Rowlands, M. (2013). Animal rights. London, UK: Hodder & Stoughton.

Sandøe, P., & Christiansen, S. B. (2013). Ethics of animal use. John Wiley & Sons.

Villanueva, G. N. (2016). There are a lot more problems with the dairy industry than the price of milk. Retrieved from https://www.businessinsider.com.au/there-are-a-lot-more-problems-with-the-dairy-industry-than-the-price-of-milk-2016-5